Yes, I got this for me. The Sweater that is...the man was NOT in the box. I was looking for a gray cardigan for my daughter and the choices were few and far between. I did manage to find something for her but also managed to find something for me. Her sweater reviewed here. I thought this was perfect, but a bit dismayed that it was Men's. I ordered my normal size ..Medium.
On me. I could go down a size but I like the look - what I was going for.
Here it is closed and sleeves rolled down. I would not wear it this way because it looks really oversized. I do roll the sleeves twice.
At the shoulder. Again, if my J Crew carried this item I might be compelled to go and try the small on. I would suggest if buying men's, size down. In my defense the size chart did say 38 chest. I really like it big and am happy with the fit.